AI Search Competitive Analysis: How to See Which Competitors AI Recommends

Quick answer: An AI search competitive analysis shows which brands ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, and Google’s AI answers recommend for the questions your buyers ask, and why. You build a fixed set of buyer prompts, run them across engines, record who gets named and cited, calculate each brand’s share of AI voice, then trace the sources behind your competitors’ citations so you know exactly what to fix.

Key Takeaways

  • Your AI competitors aren’t always your SERP competitors. AI answers often name brands that rank poorly in Google but get mentioned a lot elsewhere.
  • Prompts replace keywords. The unit of analysis is a buyer question, run several times per engine, not a single keyword ranking.
  • Share of AI voice is the headline metric. It shows your slice of all brand mentions across your prompt set.
  • The sources matter more than the answers. The pages AI cites for competitors become your PR, review, and content roadmap.
  • Free data exists. Bing Webmaster Tools now reports your citation share by grounding query, and Search Console reports AI Overview and AI Mode appearances.

What Is an AI Search Competitive Analysis?

A traditional SEO competitive analysis compares rankings, backlinks, and keyword gaps. An AI search competitive analysis compares something different: which brands AI engines name, link to, and describe favorably when a buyer asks for help. Because AI answers are written fresh each time, you measure patterns across many runs instead of a single position.

It answers three questions. Who does AI recommend in your category? How often are you included compared with them? And what are competitors doing, on their sites and across the web, that earns those mentions?

Step 1: Find the Competitors AI Actually Names

Start with your known competitors, then let the engines tell you who else matters. Ask ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, and Google AI Mode open category questions such as “best [product type] for [use case]” and “alternatives to [your brand].” Note every brand that appears more than once. Smaller brands with strong review profiles or heavy Reddit discussion often show up here even if they barely rank in Google.

Keep the final list to five to eight competitors so the analysis stays manageable.

Step 2: Build a Buyer Prompt Set

Write 30 to 50 prompts that mirror how real buyers research. Cover each stage of the journey so you can see where you win and where you disappear.

Prompt type Example What it reveals
Category “Best lifting straps for heavy deadlifts” Who AI treats as the category leaders
Problem “How do I stop my grip failing on pulls?” Whether you appear before the buyer knows what to buy
Comparison “[Your brand] vs [competitor]” How AI frames your strengths and weaknesses
Alternatives “Alternatives to [competitor]” Whether you’re seen as a credible switch option
Brand “Is [your brand] worth it?” Accuracy and sentiment of what AI says about you

Pull real wording from your Search Console queries, site search, customer service tickets, and review text. Lock the list once it’s set so month-over-month results stay comparable.

Step 3: Run the Prompts and Record Four Things

Run every prompt on each engine you care about, ideally three or more times, because AI answers vary between runs. For each run, record:

  1. Mention: is the brand named at all?
  2. Citation: is the brand’s site linked as a source?
  3. Placement: is it the first recommendation, one of several, or a passing mention?
  4. Framing: is the description positive, neutral, negative, or wrong?

A spreadsheet works for a first pass. For ongoing tracking, an AI visibility tool can run the prompts on a schedule and log competitors automatically. Our AI visibility tool comparison covers the main options and their pricing.

Step 4: Calculate Share of AI Voice

Share of AI voice is the percentage of all brand mentions in your prompt set that belong to each brand. If your five competitors and you are mentioned 200 times in total across all runs, and you account for 30 of those, your share of AI voice is 15%.

Break it down by prompt type and by engine. Most brands find a clear pattern, such as strong presence in brand and comparison prompts but near-zero presence in category and problem prompts, which is where new customers come from.

Step 5: Trace the Sources Behind Competitor Citations

This is the step most teams skip, and it’s the most useful. For every answer that recommends a competitor, look at the sources the engine cites or links. Group them into types:

  • Review and comparison sites where competitors are listed and you are not.
  • Reddit and forum threads where customers recommend competitors by name.
  • Editorial roundups and trade publications that feature competitors.
  • Competitor pages such as comparison pages, guides, or FAQs that AI quotes directly.

The first three become your digital PR and review outreach list. The fourth becomes your content gap list. Our guide on how to get cited by AI covers how to earn those mentions.

Step 6: Compare the Pages That Win

When a competitor’s own page gets cited, study why. Look for a direct answer in the first few lines, clear headings that match the question, comparison tables, original data, recent update dates, and named authors. Then compare your closest page against it point by point. Usually the gap is structure and specificity rather than length.

Free Data That Helps the Analysis

  • Bing Webmaster Tools AI Performance report: shows the grounding queries behind citations of your site in Copilot and Bing AI answers, including your citation share for each query. A low citation share on a high-value query tells you competitors are taking most of the citations.
  • Google Search Console: shows queries where your pages appear in AI Overviews and AI Mode, which helps you choose which prompts to prioritize.
  • GA4: an AI referral channel group shows which competitor-contested topics actually send you visitors once you start winning citations.

Turn the Findings Into a 90-Day Plan

  1. Days 1 to 30: fix inaccurate brand facts, refresh the three pages closest to winning citations, and claim any review profiles competitors have and you don’t.
  2. Days 31 to 60: publish the comparison and problem-focused pages your gap list calls for, and start outreach to the publications and roundups citing competitors.
  3. Days 61 to 90: rerun the full prompt set, compare share of AI voice by stage and engine, and reset priorities.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

  • Judging from one run. A single answer can be an outlier. Look at rates across runs.
  • Changing the prompt set every month. You lose the ability to compare over time.
  • Only tracking ChatGPT. Different engines pull from different sources, so competitors often win on one and lose on another.
  • Ignoring wrong information. Being described inaccurately can cost more than not being mentioned.

Get an AI Search Competitive Analysis From National Positions

National Positions runs AI search competitive analyses for ecommerce brands, benchmarking your share of AI voice against competitors across ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, and Google’s AI results, then building the content and PR plan to close the gap. Book a call to see where you stand, or learn more about our AI search optimization services.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many prompts do I need for an AI search competitive analysis?

Thirty to fifty prompts covering category, problem, comparison, alternative, and brand questions is enough for most brands. Run each one several times per engine so results reflect patterns rather than one-off answers.

What is share of AI voice?

Share of AI voice is the percentage of all brand mentions across your prompt set that belong to a given brand. It shows how much of the AI conversation in your category you own compared with competitors.

How often should I rerun the analysis?

Monthly tracking of a core prompt set works well, with a full competitive review every quarter. AI answers shift often, so trends over several months matter more than any single check.

Can I do this without paid tools?

Yes. Manual prompt checks in a spreadsheet, plus Bing Webmaster Tools and Google Search Console, cover the basics. Paid trackers save time once you track many prompts or several engines.

Sources & References

Recents Posts

Subscribe by Email

Get the latest insights delivered straight to your inbox.

Need Help With Your Strategy?

Our team of growth experts can help you build a performance-driven marketing plan.

Your Custom Strategy Is Waiting

Our strategies go beyond eBooks. Let’s build a growth plan tailored to your business.